Georgie Porgie’s Flavor of the Day

When you’re in the frozen custard capital of the world, you’ve got to stand out. Our Wisconsin custard is made fresh daily at our Oak Creek restaurant and our Mt. Pleasant restaurant. We feature a unique Flavor of the Day along with vanilla and chocolate custard daily and our famous Butter Pecan every Friday.

Download Flavor Forecast

APRIL FORECAST

BUTTER PECAN SERVED EVERY FRIDAY!
Death by Chocolate — Rich chocolate custard loaded with chocolate pieces
Heath — Vanilla custard with Heath toffee pieces
Closed — Closed for a day of prayers and rest.
GP Delight — Vanilla custard, chocolate flakes, salted pecans
Oreo Explosion — Oreo custard, Oreo’s, fudge, marshmallow crème
Oatmeal Cream Pie — Vanilla custard, oatmeal cream pie chunks, caramel
Jungle Jimmies — Vanilla custard, frosted animal crackers, rainbow jimmies
Double Chocolate Chip — Chocolate custard, cookie dough, chocolate flakes
Super Snickers — Vanilla custard, Snickers, caramel swirls & chopped nuts
Closed — Closed for a day of prayer and rest
Pineapple Upside Down Cake — Vanilla custard, pineapple, yellow cake pcs & maraschino cherry halves
Boston Creme Pie — Vanilla custard, yellow cake pcs, vanilla pudding & fudge swirls
Banana Split — Vanilla custard, banana slices, strawberries, pineapple, chopped nuts & chocolate flakes
Tabby Kat — Chocolate custard, caramel sauce, KitKat candy pcs
Peanut M&M — Vanilla custard, M&M, chopped nuts
Cookie Butter Crunch — Vanilla custard, Biscoff cookies, cookie butter
Closed — Closed for day of prayer & rest
Cherry Cheesecake — Vanilla custard, cheesecake pcs & cherry topping
German Chocolate — Chocolate custard, coconut shavings, chocolate flakes, caramel, pecans
Apple Pie — Vanilla custard, apple pie filling & graham cracker pcs
Waffle Noffle — Chocolate custard, strawberries, caramel, waffle cone pcs, Nutella swirls

May FORECAST

BUTTER PECAN SERVED EVERY FRIDAY!
Chocolate M&M — Chocolate custard, M&M pieces
Strawberry Shortcake — Vanilla custard, strawberries, yellow cake pieces
Closed — Closed for a day of prayers and rest
PB Delight — Chocolate custard, peanut butter cups, peanut butter sauce
Funky Monkey — Vanilla custard, peanut butter cups, banana slices, fudge
Double Chocolate Chip — Chocolate custard, cookie dough pieces, chocolate flakes
Caramel Cake— Vanilla custard, caramel, yellow cake pieces
Blueberry Lemon Pie — Vanilla custard, blueberry pie filling, lemon pudding, graham crackers
Sarah’s Delight — Chocolate custard, Oreo's
Closed — Closed for a day of prayers and rest
Drummy — Vanilla custard with waffle cone pieces, nuts & chocolate flakes
White Chocolate Mocha — Mocha flavored custard, white chocolate sauce, chocolate flakes
Chocolate Eclair — Vanilla custard, eclair shells, vanilla pudding, fudge
Twikz — Vanilla custard, graham crackers, chocolate flakes, caramel
Buster Brownie — Vanilla custard, brownie chunks, peanut butter sauce, fudge
Heath Heaven — Vanilla custard, yellow cake pieces, caramel, Heath Ba
Closed — Closed for a day of prayers and rest
Snickers — Vanilla custard, Snickers
Peanut M&M — Vanilla custard, M&M, chopped nuts
Take 5.5 — Vanilla custard, pretzel pieces, peanut butter sauce, chocolate flakes, caramel
Chocolate Malt Crunch — Chocolate malt custard, Whopper pieces
Raspberry Cheesecake — Vanilla custard, cheesecake pieces, raspberries
M&M Crunch — Vanilla custard, M&M, graham cracker, fudge swirls
Closed — Closed for a day of prayers and rest
Closed — Closed! Happy Memorial Day!
Nutella Banana Crunch — Vanilla custard, banana slices, waffle pieces, Nutella swirls
Strawberry Oreo — Vanilla custard, strawberries, Oreo pieces
Chocolate Craze — Chocolate custard, brownie pieces, fudge swirls, chocolate flakes
Cherry Pie — Vanilla custard, cherry topping, graham cracker pieces
Beach Bum — Vanilla custard, caramel swirls, shortbread cookies, sea salt
Closed — Closed for a day of prayers and rest